Peanut Butter Pie$6.00 You asked…We listened! Be sure to try our New Peanut Butter Pie. *Made with artificial peanut flavoring. Peanut Butter Pie quantity Add to cart Category: Cheesecake Mixes Related products Pistachio Cheesecake Mix $6.00 Add to Cart A Pistachio flavor that will catapult you to a new level. Amazing! *Made with artificial pistachio flavoring. More... English Toffee Cheesecake Mix $6.00 Add to Cart A delicate taste of caramelized brown sugar combined with butter and a dash of vanilla. Simply delicious! More... Spiced Pumpkin Cheesecake Mix $6.00 Add to Cart A precise blend of cinnamon and ginger combined with the phenomenal flavor of pumpkin makes this cheesecake a perfect ending to any meal or get-together! More...